Is the Peace that passes all understanding the same as absence of war? When Jesus gives us His Peace is He telling us not to make war? Or, is He speaking of Peace as the opposite of war? If so, He is not God as some of us suppose.
The war-like God of Moses is here speaking to us in the person of Jesus Christ. In the historical context He is speaking to people who have not known a war for the better part of a century. In their lifetimes they have no memory of war. What is He talking about when He says, "My Peace I give you."
At mass there's a point where everybody in the congregation turns to offer in words and by some gesture the Peace of Christ to the ones near them. It always makes my eyes wet to do this, silly girl that I am.
When I pray for peace I get peace. When I pray that this person over here does what I would like him to do and that person over there does what I want her to do I don't get that. I would like that my old friend J- should have not died a few days ago, but he did. I would like that the girl I loved had loved me back, but she didn't. I would like that my sons would do everything I tell them to do when I tell them to do it, but they don't.
I don't believe the Peace of Christ has anything to do with removing the Free Will of our neighbors. Nor is He instructing us to kill everybody who doesn't do what we would like him to do, or think as we would like him to think, and we know when we are angry that is precisely what we are doing - killing.
Christ lived in a period of stability - peace, as some people define it, the absence of war enforced by the power of Rome. It would not be very long after the Resurrection that Rome's oppressive stranglehold over the known world would begin to be seriously challenged. Shortly after Christ's crucifixion the Jewish people would rebel against the power of Rome, which many of them had been itching to do for a while - naturally.
I say 'naturally' because I also say "Give me liberty or give me death," - not Give me peace or give me death, or Give me security or give me death, or Give me safety or give me death. If someone tries to take my liberty, or my neighbor's liberty, I will make righteous war. Peace is what will follow after my victory.
That stability - that absence of war - is what I call The Peace of Rome.
But, when I pray to God for Peace - not to Rome for peace - I always receive Peace. The more I do it the more quickly - immediately - I seem to receive it. Nothing about the outer world has changed, but I have peace. I've also learned that I can offer this same peace to my neighbors, and that they can either receive it or reject it as it pleases them.
I don't quite know how to describe it except to say that it is a stillness in which I am in attendance to God and able to hear Him. I call it the Peace of Christ, the Peace of God.
But, the really interesting bit is this: While I say outer conditions haven't changed as a result of my prayer for Peace, I have found that over time they do. And while people still don't do what I would like them to do, or think what I would like them to think, they often seem to discover another option I had not imagined for them. When I pray for Peace the people around me do begin to change in subtle ways so that they no longer offer me the same trouble they once did.
I think the trick is to receive God's Peace, not to demand that I become God - not to tell God what I think this one should do or that one should do. I think when many people say they are praying for peace that's what they are really praying for - that other people should believe in particular things or behave in a particular way, that Free Will should be suspended.
One way to do that is the way of Rome - to sufficiently oppress the will of others so that they have not the strength to rise against you. But of course, one day they will, just as I would. One day they will, and they may lose or they may win, but your evil empire will eventually topple just like that brazen tower back in Bible days.
A hundred years of peace under Rome is like a single day to history, following which are several hundred years of wars.
No, I don't think Christ's Peace has anything to do with wars.
Now - if only everybody in the world would do as I do and think as I think, and prayed for Peace the way I pray for Peace, then I know there would be world peace. I guarantee it. I couldn't guarantee it would last longer than the space of time in which that prayer was made, but in those moments there would be world peace.
So - are you prepared to make me your God? Are you prepared to surrender your will to me and do as I tell you, and behave yourself as I tell you to behave?
No?
Well, it just so happens I'm not prepared to make you my God either, and if you try to control me I will make war against you. And in my heart I'll be at Peace doing it, too.
See? I'll rise up and fight against the Peace of Rome, but the Peace of Christ is something completely different. It is received instantaneously the moment it is prayed for, and nobody can take it away from those of us who have it.
So, when people get together to pray for Peace are they praying to God or are they praying to Rome? It's easy to tell. If they are praying to God then you will see that they are receiving His Peace. But if they are really praying to Rome they'll come out of that prayer just as angry, rotten, and miserable as they were when they went into it.
Who's the silly girl then? His eyes become wet in the church, all because of a handshake and some mumbled words of Peace.